A record from the Factory repository, docs/review-receipt.json, shown as committed except that its local paths appear as placeholders in angle brackets, such as <local evidence archive>, standing for files that are not published. Its private session identifiers appear as numbered placeholders, such as <private session 1>, one number for each session in this record. Every hash, date and count is as recorded. The build review says what the Factory's receipts support.
{
"date": "2026-09-28T00:40:42.824956+00:00",
"scope": "Clarity revision: completed Opus max rewrite, independent Fable max and Astra ultra review, findings returned to Opus max for bounded corrections; existing 27-epic map preserved.",
"baseline_commit": "77dfa8c",
"requested_round_completed": true,
"effort_note": "Claude Code supports max rather than ultra. All completed Opus and Fable contributions in this round used max; Astra used ultra. The previous epic synthesis has its own historical receipt at the baseline commit.",
"completed": [
{
"phase": "opus-language",
"session_id": "<private session 1>",
"result": "success",
"is_error": false,
"models_observed": [
"claude-opus-5-5"
],
"response_sha256": "1a037961984b5d07693d95505c2998e757d7fd0134190fd3a1d0bb3489ba3b24",
"structured": true,
"effort": "max",
"tool": "Claude Code 2.1.283",
"final_text_sha256": "fdc990cd07a7855d4c664b056e7070c8d0b84af90088ee905e933d144f091302"
},
{
"phase": "opus-page-1",
"session_id": "<private session 2>",
"result": "success",
"is_error": false,
"models_observed": [
"claude-opus-5-5"
],
"response_sha256": "3b19541a5b512caee09444f7fc6350cb59104a7d4a39082a7f7fdf3faa4e6b85",
"structured": false,
"effort": "max",
"tool": "Claude Code 2.1.283",
"final_text_sha256": "5b31a354317081882a5550c315b078377a4415f9d14531771ca74b12ba97a8c2"
},
{
"phase": "opus-page-2",
"session_id": "<private session 3>",
"result": "success",
"is_error": false,
"models_observed": [
"claude-opus-5-5"
],
"response_sha256": "25679b52e2608588fb440ab383d8a78cb77707c15d4a36b45bfddb8f715dfbb7",
"structured": false,
"effort": "max",
"tool": "Claude Code 2.1.283",
"final_text_sha256": "51309647287364ccbac80cbc9f72ff95f9669cb1703f46432cd6f8bb5021867c"
},
{
"phase": "opus-page-3",
"session_id": "<private session 4>",
"result": "success",
"is_error": false,
"models_observed": [
"claude-opus-5-5"
],
"response_sha256": "89bdbfd035e34eb88f9bee0d77322a79ba9349456ddc0b8a074cffef74c80b03",
"structured": false,
"effort": "max",
"tool": "Claude Code 2.1.283",
"final_text_sha256": "e789ed2f321119b6cd7e89677bf278638937e81e2532fabba7910f337d02295a"
},
{
"phase": "opus-page-4",
"session_id": "<private session 5>",
"result": "success",
"is_error": false,
"models_observed": [
"claude-opus-5-5"
],
"response_sha256": "c4e4cd8e7ffe953095f105ce370d102db4673c47b6e99542de8b6c2005d691a7",
"structured": false,
"effort": "max",
"tool": "Claude Code 2.1.283",
"final_text_sha256": "dd123d4a9242be0ce553025445fbc12717c62855c8173fa4d5da3dcb49768116"
},
{
"phase": "opus-page-5",
"session_id": "<private session 6>",
"result": "success",
"is_error": false,
"models_observed": [
"claude-opus-5-5"
],
"response_sha256": "f649e2b4fc590fd98c04c91056e30051b6f858d23455aa2a92eb254277fce744",
"structured": false,
"effort": "max",
"tool": "Claude Code 2.1.283",
"final_text_sha256": "b4fffa8f2cb7e7f9950bb0b9a99aca37be238703e28490b5013a14591a5f2b48"
},
{
"phase": "opus-atlas",
"session_id": "<private session 7>",
"result": "success",
"is_error": false,
"models_observed": [
"claude-opus-5-5"
],
"response_sha256": "1cd7d35dca7a59221875c18d1a643cbc416a0fb1dcd8452b78fb6e06988d1dfb",
"structured": false,
"effort": "max",
"tool": "Claude Code 2.1.283",
"final_text_sha256": "017327da986cbe24982d13ee59ce72ea05aee5c1bc64f7768e5182ce4f27726e"
},
{
"phase": "fable-review",
"session_id": "<private session 8>",
"result": "success",
"is_error": false,
"models_observed": [
"claude-fable-5-1"
],
"response_sha256": "e9ba3ea2a6a5fdb2edd8c55e91950a2e7e0313c89018a8c71cbaeeddf504f9cd",
"structured": false,
"effort": "max",
"tool": "Claude Code 2.1.283",
"final_text_sha256": "ae096de55db9bda9a789dcb0c1923ff491025d6f8fe7dab4beea73a15117c60f"
},
{
"phase": "opus-final-short",
"session_id": "<private session 9>",
"result": "success",
"is_error": false,
"models_observed": [
"claude-opus-5-5"
],
"response_sha256": "b5d73e9028eea5603b889766d75a9ebd681635a92e2e752f91cc3b02ff0d39d8",
"structured": true,
"effort": "max",
"tool": "Claude Code 2.1.283",
"final_text_sha256": "9a480393df0c539428e6d882ca82750322c162dc4e841441d4788619b78af898"
},
{
"phase": "opus-final-contracts",
"session_id": "<private session 10>",
"result": "success",
"is_error": false,
"models_observed": [
"claude-opus-5-5"
],
"response_sha256": "4c73283f208a7adcdc42dfcf6d46e17fb54b6fc3153259d196453b552901eb0c",
"structured": true,
"effort": "max",
"tool": "Claude Code 2.1.283",
"final_text_sha256": "abaee0c25cbac540305cb96aca32802a58e629b29c64dc538608898f320ce9a0"
},
{
"phase": "opus-final-page-5",
"session_id": "<private session 11>",
"result": "success",
"is_error": false,
"models_observed": [
"claude-opus-5-5"
],
"response_sha256": "5aef62581c441c0e4beece019dc8d5a761168fdc523d99128430fca5b02c0f56",
"structured": false,
"effort": "max",
"tool": "Claude Code 2.1.283",
"final_text_sha256": "26e44fae313dbe4834b18f03e7174ae4b8f8657c67903946ce5d83f0d88cb6d8"
},
{
"phase": "opus-final-atlas",
"session_id": "<private session 12>",
"result": "success",
"is_error": false,
"models_observed": [
"claude-opus-5-5"
],
"response_sha256": "44f4f5a8b5cd56632354a52a9eb27d83e0065b3a22c87267b17ca47c34b03aff",
"structured": false,
"effort": "max",
"tool": "Claude Code 2.1.283",
"final_text_sha256": "ca74e16c7e0185c1b69b98273bc7312ead30c048d58c585087cacb6179e519e4"
},
{
"phase": "astra-review",
"model": "gpt-6-astra",
"effort": "ultra",
"result": "completed",
"agent": "<home directory path>",
"final_text_sha256": "a64534599393e4747185ebb3e66decdffdc5f81503f49e8a9eb6cfeb114d5358"
},
{
"phase": "astra-final-check",
"model": "gpt-6-astra",
"effort": "ultra",
"result": "completed; one terminology correction applied",
"agent": "<home directory path>",
"final_text_sha256": "ef5693ab67a16363d4719681fda891d717a505efe7d8718bbafad40e4e4bb380"
}
],
"incomplete_attempts": [
{
"phase": "opus-rewrite",
"model": "claude-opus-5-5",
"effort": "max",
"response_sha256": "d363b4dcfa2f882b60be1dd9dc2317afab71737ed4d09dfc1991bf76a7697844",
"status": "stopped without completed final text; not counted as a rewrite or review"
},
{
"phase": "opus-rewrite-expanded",
"model": "claude-opus-5-5",
"effort": "max",
"response_sha256": "3cf8ac980498d4777739e4744aaa83489fe4ab33a3050fd106bc403e3e180210",
"status": "stopped without completed final text; not counted as a rewrite or review"
},
{
"phase": "opus-design",
"model": "claude-opus-5-5",
"effort": "max",
"response_sha256": "3b5547c9c067c7c93ddaee1765741f61ed4d22737900cdda7e7adf68fdb7f5c2",
"status": "stopped without completed final text; not counted as a rewrite or review"
},
{
"phase": "opus-final-evolution",
"model": "claude-opus-5-5",
"effort": "max",
"response_sha256": "c5a2cedcd9ed4fbc372f5b93cf3557645c728fd06a6d3f9c3526e65a7d95d788",
"status": "stopped without completed final text; not counted as a rewrite or review"
}
],
"unused_alternative": {
"phase": "opus-brief",
"status": "completed at max, not selected: excessive length and absolute risk wording"
},
"review_feedback_sent": {
"opus-final-short": "db5e29d14102d85390a9447ee72b14845d91cda5fe28d9c629df9ff3ed116083",
"opus-final-contracts": "7e3b2ecd6d15e54f6382f2a8b5669cbe867d3fa81fc955f622423b02e0191ad3",
"opus-final-evolution": "0686303a987b4583e24b9bc93af165abc1b3f2e9aafc4e25c08a25fa57ea74bf",
"opus-final-page-5": "2e44fb2e7ced8ed304136937849d07672736ba177b6a0c2d4ae5971f0e20fed3",
"opus-final-atlas": "71974132213cb716f5e097667d5959c49eeb1dc11ce822a1ac729f27a6f9fbdf"
},
"dispositions": {
"short": [
"A1 accepted for the one-page. A plain lifecycle now replaces the glossary opening and carries A1's candidate, verdict and assessment split. The Purpose heading is merged into the intro. The coverage/CI, reuse and cost-order lines are left to values and design. Estimated 336 words by whitespace count; the render has not been run here. Design compression is out of scope.",
"A2 and F5 applied in scope. The Action gateway checks both authority and policy. People are asked only for a decision, access or resource the factory cannot obtain within authority and budget. Diagram and design guards are out of scope.",
"A3 out of scope. Command, event, dispatch and fencing detail is removed from the one-page, as instructed.",
"A4: no in-scope edit. Both views already use evidence to choose and justify work.",
"A5 and F3 out of scope. The one-page never says Operations verifies.",
"A6 and F2 applied. Assurance checks the measurement, then Planning records the assessment as Supported, Rejected or Inconclusive. Only Supported counts as value. The Assurance row adds measurement verification.",
"A7 applied. The brief uses sentence case and has separate recovery and blocker sentences, bounded by owner-granted authority; 89 words. 'Proposed stack' is design-only.",
"F1 applied: Planning decides retirement.",
"F4 partial. The Operations row adds vendor access. Per-product customer identity is left to the design as an existing obligation, not a new service.",
"F6 applied: three foundations, shared by all domains.",
"F7 out of scope. The one-page keeps independent recovery and the drill gate before unattended self-update.",
"F8: 'potentially unsafe' and escalation wording applied. Treating every security exposure as an incident is rejected; baseline severity deadlines stand. Run, Product, budget, fitness and Objective items are out of scope.",
"Reconciled: policy may change within authority without owner approval; only owners widen authority.",
"Term hygiene: 'recovery targets' keeps 'objective' to one meaning, and 'finished work or a release' replaces 'Run completion'."
],
"contracts": [
"A1 accept for design \u00a72: removed the Planning and Evidence store glossary rows, including 'formerly called Product'. Compressed the Capabilities subsection to disposition vs health, safe restoration, the Planning decision, independent baseline verification and binding obligations, with a link to Self-improvement. The one-page view and the re-render belong to companion tasks.",
"Length: \u00a7\u00a71\u20134 now have about 25 fewer words, two fewer table rows and two fewer paragraph breaks. \u00a75 must supply the rest of the cut to reach \u22642,100 words and five pages.",
"A2 accept in design: Escalation now requires that no permitted remedy remains within current Authority and Budget, and it asks for the missing decision, access or resource. The glossary is aligned. The view 6 guard is deferred to the atlas task.",
"A3 accept: a dispatch is defined as one external call, not a new worker Attempt or logical Action. The idempotency key is renamed Action key. Epoch is explained as an increasing ownership version. 'Model calls run as bounded Attempts' is corrected.",
"A4 accept: Evidence now covers justifying work, verifying Candidates and assessing released changes. Signal is narrowed to indicating a possible need.",
"A5 accept, superseding the F3 wording: Operations integrates only the Candidate covered by Assurance's current Verdict. Invalidation is kept.",
"A6 accept: an Assessment is Planning's comparison with a stated conclusion. Step 5 and the value-win rule are revised. Availability is now 'confirmed' so that verifying stays with Assurance.",
"A7 partial: 'Proposed stack' accepted. Brief edits belong to the companion task.",
"F1 accept: Planning decides retirement within Authority (table and \u00a72).",
"F2 accept: Assurance independently checks instrumentation, segment effects and decision-rule application. The Assessment rests on that independently checked Evidence.",
"F3 accept via the A5 wording.",
"F4 accept as existing obligations, not new services: Operations owns vendor access, and each Product has its own customer identities by default.",
"F5, F6 and F7 deferred to the atlas and \u00a75 companion tasks.",
"F8 partial accept: Evidence (as in A4), Run with pinned inputs and accountable scope, Product, Escalation, Objective and the worker comparison. The security bullet is reconciled to severity deadlines rather than blanket incidents. 'Explicit spend Authority' is rejected here because its text was not supplied. One-page items go to the companion task.",
"Reconciliation: Policy is defined as operating rules the factory may revise within Authority, so no owner gate is added.",
"Propagation into supporting records (both reviews) is out of scope for this task."
],
"evolution": [
"Applied the scoped recovery, evolution, build-order and atlas corrections from A1/A2/A6 and F5/F6/F7; coordinator synthesis of the completed text."
]
},
"final_sources": {
"docs/brief.md": "9ad7e3d932fb5c24dc316abadc7c270cac6de31786ea34de441f2275213b6d3d",
"docs/one-page.md": "3956dee7808afedb5983c732a45a3ffd2aeca36eed9d96a64e5cfe18fc46371a",
"docs/design.md": "87313c919b6f19e3632f5093974bacd26b0514f919cdbc20a083ba15471559ca",
"docs/architecture.md": "ca9bc43f96439040262b23bf484f7492a7f7953b6eba3e84b00dd98a428ed9d4",
"docs/values.md": "8c57af9386d71c99eaadfbc849d16e92956b6ea3415b86282c54a91313d79b68",
"docs/self-improvement.md": "d189859b40b0842f2f3e9120afd0c785ea87247a0e0c6f1fdaba76bdc1eb4e9b",
"docs/first-slice.md": "edf61209b7cd90fffd6f8df28b98ef92130bdf91b3ce8348f0931199e1103643",
"docs/epics.json": "8d6f62831ef3bb78e1598248c2ac9b4da22c09221755ced5d298bf79ea79cd97",
"docs/implementation.md": "9898041e3619dc7acf27b25fcf83cb1c21fcce8fbafca67210c071e904976f6c",
"docs/review.md": "4f519d6eceeab993dab93c890acf2c3bf18cd46a03d3292e4b52d9d94c66508d",
".intent/project.md": "3db7405342fea2e8d6065467b2a96bd6df5399188ba0fe360a51fb7354a235dd",
"README.md": "8b07cdaa8bbdfe92b2835f43e2d86fa8b701d244e46745730844042bede8215c",
"scripts/render_docs.py": "cee28f0df42b116afee4dc0f6be18d438b5337880cb970db57d8b4ea366d9e3f",
"scripts/render_epics.py": "4163a36e153e35b07feabd5e8ff6b8be9076e06e914b753deabff87dab67be4d"
},
"validation": {
"all_22_pages_visually_inspected": true,
"local_markdown_links_resolve": true,
"six_svg_files_parse": true,
"epics": 27,
"epic_ids_and_dependencies_unchanged": true,
"word_counts": {
"docs/brief.md": 89,
"docs/one-page.md": 336,
"docs/design.md": 2071,
"docs/architecture.md": 705
},
"pdf_pages": {
"output/pdf/software-factory-diagrams.pdf": 6,
"output/pdf/software-factory-five-pages.pdf": 5,
"output/pdf/software-factory-implementation-guide.pdf": 10,
"output/pdf/software-factory-one-page.pdf": 1
},
"runtime_claim": "Document assurance only; no factory runtime or production reliability is established."
}
}